The question of how to clear up acne scars fast is one that is achievable if you find what works for you. I understand that people choose to adopt a skin care approach based on a variety of reasons that include efficacy, tolerance, prize and belief -medical vs organic etc.
I have chosen to REVIEW AND COMPARE TWO tea tree based products that promise to help clear up acne scars fast.
In this article, I will share with you some very important principles you might want to consider before deciding on which product to buy for your acne/acne scars. I’ll consider the following products for this purpose;
1) Cystic Acne & Scar Herbal Cream
2) 1001 Remedies/Magic Skin/Skin Repair Gel
(As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases. Full disclosure…)
My short story – before products review
As I have mentioned in my previous article, my passion about organic and natural skin care for acne is not only based on my knowledge, but also on the fact that they have worked for people that I have close relationship with and care about – my wife and sister.
They both had similar experiences with acne – it was persistent into their adulthood. Feeling frustrated about the ineffectiveness and intolerance to products prescribed by their doctors, they turned to organic and natural skin care.
Before long, they found out what worked for them – both have different skin types and different routines. Eventually, they were able to get their acne under control!
Sharing what works is always helpful and may add value to one’s quality of life. However, I want to also acknowledge that there will still be a population of acne sufferers who may not respond to what works for others. This is where you need to see a dermatologist. Also, a visit to a dermatologist is recommended for those with severe acne.
PRINCIPLES before deciding on a product
If you are considering organic option for acne, I believe you WANT the answer to these 5 QUESTIONS (essential principles) to be YES
- Does the product work?
- Is it a quality product (i.e. quality over quantity)?
- Is it affordable?
- Is it safe and tolerable?
- Does it give fast result or in reasonable time?
Product Comparison
I have come up with this table to track how these two products compare in fulfillment of the relevant 5 principles mentioned above.
| Cystic Acne & Scars Herbal Cream | 1001 Remedies/Magic Skin/Skin Repair Gel | |
| YES – 30 Day Money Back Guarantee | Yes – 30 Day Money Back Guarantee |
| Australia | France |
| 4.3 Star rating out of 5 | 4.8 star rating out of 5 |
| $47.90 | $39.00 |
| Specified for Scars, Redness, Dark Spots, Acne, Inflammation, Pores, Oiliness
Can be used on face and body Can be used by male and female | Specified for Scars, suitable for Acne, Psoriasis, Rosacea, Blackhead & Acne Prone Skin
Can be used on face and body Can be used by both male and female |
| Not specified but based on users’ experiences, it’s worked on various skin types | All body types, including oily, young, combination, mature, normal |
| YES | YES |
| Ensure skin is cleansed, apply small amount to affected area and gently rub it in until you feel it has penetrated into your skin
Avoid direct sunlight post application Recommended routine: 2-3 times a day or as required | Same process. Recommends tea tree wash prior to applying product.
Avoid direct sun exposure about 2 hours post application Recommended routine: twice a day |
| 18 January 2021 | 31 December 2018 |
Awards
- Cystic Acne & Scar Herbal Cream: Amazon’s Choice.
- 1001 Remedies/Magic Skin/Skin Repair Gel: Voted twice by Financial Times as the “best beauty product”. It also has received awards, including Natural Health International Beauty Awards 2018 and Green Parent Natural Beauty Awards 2018 SILVER.
Comparing Products Ingredients
SPECIAL INGREDIENTS
- TEA TREE OIL
Cystic Acne & Scar Herbal Cream: YES
1001 Remedies/Magic Skin/Skin Repair Gel: YES
Benefits: Kills microbes (including acne causing bacteria), reduces sebum (oil) production, has healing properties.
- ALOE VERA
Cystic Acne & Scar Herbal Cream: YES
1001 Remedies/Magic Skin/Skin Repair Gel: YES
Benefits: Has healing properties, reduces redness/depigmentation, protects from UV radiation, contains antioxidants, anti-aging, moisturizes and hydrates the skin.
- ROSEHIP OIL
Cystic Acne & Scar Herbal Cream: YES
1001 Remedies/Magic Skin/Skin Repair Gel: NO
Benefits: Anti-inflammatory, antioxidant, fights acne, reduces pigmentation, scars and fine lines
- SALICYLIC ACID
Cystic Acne & Scar Herbal Cream: NO
1001 Remedies/Magic Skin/Skin Repair Gel: YES
Benefits: Anti-inflammatory, unclog pores and reduces their size, prevents re-clogging of pores.
- ORGANIC ESSENTIAL OILS
Cystic Acne & Scar Herbal Cream: YES
1001 Remedies/Magic Skin/Skin Repair Gel: YES
Benefits: Soothing, moisturize, heal and fade scars, antimicrobial, fight acne, reduce pigmentation, unique fresh smell.
Users’ Experience
A concrete way you can determine how effective a product has been among its buyers is by looking at the users’ experiences.
You can view customers’ reviews on Amazon
Pros and Cons
1) 1001 Remedies/Magic Skin/Skin Repair Gel – (4 Pros, 1 Con)
This product fulfills 4 out of 5 core questions/principles we have established
- Does the product work? ….. YES
- Is it a quality product (i.e. quality over quantity)? ….. YES
- Is it affordable NO (Quality but pricey)
- Is it safe and tolerable?…. YES
- Does it give fast result or in reasonable time?…. YES : most of its users report results within days to weeks
2) Cystic Acne & Scar Herbal Cream (it’s all pros!)
This product fulfills 5 out of 5 core questions/principles established
- Does the product work? ….. YES
- Is it a quality product (i.e. quality over quantity)? ….. YES
- Is it affordable?…. YES
- Is it safe and tolerable?…. YES
- Does it give fast result or in reasonable time?…. YES : most of its users report results within days to weeks
Verdict
It’s hard to pick a winner just because one has to. However, on this occasion, I’ll pick the Cystic Acne & Scars Herbal Cream as the WINNER here. It has a marginal edge over 1001 Remedies/Magic Skin/Skin Repair Gel because it has been designed to also fight off cystic acne. Its claim to improve cystic acne has been attested to by many buyers.
Both products are of remarkable top-notch quality manufactured by leading brands in the cosmetic and beauty industry.
They are both effective in their claim to clear up acne scars fast, and in treating various severity of acne. They also help with other skin conditions, including rosacea and other inflammatory diseases already mentioned in this article.
Both can be used on normal/clear skin to moisturize, hydrate and protect the skin and also give that radiant and luminous skin appearance.
Generally, they are well tolerated, all natural, vegan friendly and free of filler, synthetic and harmful ingredients, and are both environmentally friendly.
However, I find that certain individuals (a small proportion of users) tend to have varying experience. For such individuals, the only way to find how your skin type would respond to these products is to try it out.
If you fall under the above category, then it means none of these products is for you. You may want to consider what works and your options may include 1) visiting a dermatologist for specialist input if you wouldn’t mind taking a medical approach, 2) trying out other organic products to find out what works best for you, 3) determine if there are other possible contributing factors you can control such as lifestyle, stress and diet.
Where to Buy
Links below;
- Cystic Acne & Scar Herbal Cream – Available on AMAZON for $47.90
- 1001 Remedies/Magic Skin/Skin Repair Gel – Available on AMAZON for $39.00
I’ll like to read from you, so please LEAVE a comment, question or review in the comment box below and I’ll reply ASAP.
Thanks Martins for the article. It’s really rich and insightful. No doubt, patronizing these products will most likely do the work. The reviews are also fine and encouraging. Your site is pleasant to read